Many people ask me why I don't review more phones, but the
truth is that I don't have access to phones for testing purposes. The phones you
see reviewed on this page have either been purchased outright, or I have taken
advantage of the generous return policies offered by Fido and Clearnet PCS.
Obviously there is a limit to how many phones I am going to buy personally, and
there is certainly a limit to how far I will stretch the generosity of Fido and
Clearnet.
What I need is a source of phones that I can borrow for the purpose of
testing. If you are in a position to lend me phones I have not tested, or you
know people who are, then I would really appreciate hearing from you. You can
e-mail me at pcsguide@rogers.com. If
you run a retail outlet, perhaps we can work out a trade involving advertising.
Words of Warning: Many newer reviews make reference to older reviews, and
this sometimes creates apparent inconsistencies in the overall assessments of
various models. Reviews are relative by nature, and so what seemed like a great
phone a year or so ago, may seem only mediocre now because other phones have
"raised the bar" so to speak. If you find that I'm being negative about a phone,
while saying it's about the same as a phone I once gave positive reviews to,
this a perfect example.
It is also possible that one phone might get a "thumbs up" assessment, while
another seemingly similar phone gets a "thumbs down" assessment. This can happen
due to the lack of a certain feature, or because a particular facet of the phone
(such as its audio quality) was poor on one, and great on another. The T28w and
T38m are good examples of this. While I didn't have a T28w to compare directly
to the T39m, I had go by my original assessment of the T28w's audio qualities,
which I remembered as being better than the T39m.
In the case "World Phones" (GSM models that support 1900 MHz as well as 900
and/or 1800 MHz) that I can only test RF performance at 1900 MHz. For all I
know, a phone that performs very poorly at 1900 MHz may in fact perform
exceedingly well at either 900 MHz or 1800 MHz. You should consider this
possibility when deciding upon a world phone. Check with reviews written outside
of North America for information about RF performance at other frequencies.
Before reading any of these reviews, please read
Some Thoughts on
Reviewing Phones.
For now however, here are the phones which I have reviewed:
|
|
|
|
Nokia
6340
11-Mar-2003 |
Siemens
S55
02-Mar-2003 |
Samsung
S105
26-Feb-2003 |
Nokia
6385
17-Feb-2003 |
|
|
|
|
Samsung
R225 / N625
07-Jan-2003 |
Motorola V120x
13-Dec-2002 |
Nokia
6310i
24-Nov-2002 |
Samsung
A520
24-Nov-2002 |
|
|
|
|
Samsung
A540
11-Nov-2002 |
Ericsson T206
06-Dec-2002 |
Nokia
3590
01-Nov-2002 |
Nokia 6188
(Second Look)
13-Oct-2000 |
|
|
|
|
Ericsson T200
15-Sep-2002 |
Motorola V60c
09-Sep-2002 |
VTech
A700
22-Aug-2002 |
Motorola A388
27-Jul-2002 |
|
|
|
|
Samsung
N105
17-Jul-2002 |
LG
TM-520
19-Sep-2002 |
Motorola P270c
05-Jun-2002 |
Motorola V60g
13-May-2002 |
|
|
|
|
Nokia
8390
10-May-2002 |
Ericsson T66
24-Apr-2002 |
Motorola V101
16-Mar-2002 |
Ericsson T68
23-Dec-2001 |
|
|
|
|
Motorola i90
13-Dec-2001 |
Motorola V66
10-Nov-2001 |
Samsung
T300
07-Nov-2001 |
Motorola i80
05-Nov-2001 |
|
|
|
|
Motorola v120c
03-Nov-2001 |
Motorola i85/i55sr
24-Oct-2001 |
Motorola P280
31-Sep-2001 |
Motorola P7389i
17-Sep-2001 |
|
|
|
|
Nokia
6185i
03-Sep-2001 |
Ericsson T39m
24-Jul-2001 |
Siemens
S40
03-Jul-2001 |
Ericsson R520m
27-Jun-2001 |
|
|
|
|
Nokia 7190
28-May-2001 |
Motorola V2282
09-Mar-2001 |
Nokia
3390
01-Mar-2002 |
Ericsson T28w
13-Nov-2000 |
|
|
|
|
Mitsubishi G310
26-Oct-2001 |
Motorola ST7867W
05-Oct-2000 |
Nokia
8890
03-Oct-2000 |
Samsung 8580
28-Aug-2000 |
|
|
|
|
Motorola Timeport
28-Aug-2000 |
Ericsson T18z
22-Mar-2000 |
Motorola L Series
07-Mar-2000 |
Sanyo SCP-4000
02-Feb-2000 |
|
|
|
|
Qualcomm 2760
16-Oct-2000 |
Nokia 6188
(Original Review)
13-Nov-2000 |
Qualcomm 1960
16-Oct-2000 |
Motorola 7797
12-Jun-2000 |
|
|
|
|
Nokia 6190
09-May-1998 |
Nokia 6185
13-Nov-2000 |
Motorola G520
24-Nov-1998 |
Mitsubishi G75
26-Nov-1999 |
|